Why Your Website Conversion Rate Is Low (7 Proven Fixes)

Gary Pettigrew

Gary Pettigrew

Cover image for Why Your Website Conversion Rate Is Low (7 Proven Fixes)

📉 Why Your Website Conversion Rate Is Low (7 Proven Fixes)

If you're getting traffic but few conversions, you're not alone. Let’s dig into the root causes — and show exactly how to fix them.


✅ Fix #1: Unclear Value Proposition

Why It Matters:
Your homepage or landing page has about 5 seconds to convince a visitor they’re in the right place. If your message is unclear or generic, most will leave without engaging.

What’s Going Wrong:

  • Generic headlines like “We Help You Grow” don’t specify how or why.

  • Listing features (e.g., “Dashboard with 7 views”) instead of benefits (e.g., “Track customer behavior in real time”).

  • Jargon-heavy content confuses people who aren’t familiar with your industry.

  • No clear differentiator makes you blend into the noise.

What to Do Instead:

  • Open with what the user gains, not what your product does.

  • Speak to a specific pain point they’re feeling.

  • Use natural language, the kind customers actually use.

  • Add a subheadline to reinforce clarity or credibility.

✏ Before/After Example:
❌ "Advanced CRM Software with Multiple Features"
✅ "Stop Losing Customers – Manage All Your Leads in One Place"


✅ Fix #2: Weak Call-to-Action Buttons

Why It Matters:
CTAs are like road signs. If they’re unclear, vague, or hard to see, users won’t take action — even if they want to.

Common Mistakes:

  • Text like “Click Here” or “Submit” is uninspiring and ambiguous.

  • Poor contrast or dull colors make CTAs visually invisible.

  • Overloaded pages with too many buttons create indecision.

  • Buttons are placed below the fold where users don’t see them.

How to Improve:

  • Write CTAs that are benefit-driven and action-oriented.

  • Make buttons pop visually using color, contrast, and size.

  • Keep focus with 1–2 primary CTAs per page.

  • Position important CTAs above the fold for immediate visibility.

💬 Better CTAs Include:

  • “Get My Free Website Audit”

  • “Start My 30-Day Trial”

  • “Download the Guide Now”


✅ Fix #3: Form Friction

Why It Matters:
Forms are often the final hurdle between a lead and a conversion. If they feel long, intrusive, or frustrating — users quit.

Where You Lose People:

  • Too many required fields feel overwhelming.

  • No mobile optimization causes misclicks or broken layouts.

  • Lack of progress indicators on multi-step forms adds uncertainty.

  • Requesting sensitive info (like phone numbers) too early kills trust.

Best Practices:

  • Ask only for the absolute essentials (e.g., name + email).

  • Use progressive profiling to get more info over time.

  • Add trust elements like privacy policies or secure icons.

  • Ensure forms are responsive and touch-friendly on all devices.

📈 Pro Tip: Cutting from 11 fields to 4 can increase conversions by up to 120%.


✅ Fix #4: Missing Social Proof

Why It Matters:
Without trust, people hesitate. Social proof shows that others have used and loved your product or service — making new visitors feel safer.

What to Include:

  • Testimonials with names/photos add authenticity.

  • Google or Facebook ratings show social validation.

  • Client logos act as recognizable trust shortcuts.

  • Usage numbers like “Over 15,000 Customers” build credibility.

  • Security badges reassure visitors about privacy and data safety.

📌 Effective Phrases:

  • “Trusted by 10,000+ users worldwide”

  • “4.9/5 Stars – Based on 275 Reviews”

  • “Watch why Sarah switched to [Your Product]”


✅ Fix #5: Poor Mobile Experience

Why It Matters:
More than 60% of web traffic comes from mobile. If your site’s mobile UX is poor, you’re alienating the majority of your audience.

Common Problems:

  • Buttons are too small to tap with a finger.

  • Pages load slowly on mobile networks.

  • Navigation is hard to use with thumb-based scrolling.

  • Pop-ups or modals are uncloseable or break layout.

Mobile Optimization Tips:

  • Use responsive design to adjust layouts automatically.

  • Create touch-friendly tap targets (at least 44px).

  • Simplify your mobile navigation and forms.

  • Optimize checkout to be quick and thumb-friendly.


✅ Fix #6: Slow Loading Speed

Why It Matters:
People are impatient. 40% of users will abandon your site if it takes longer than 3 seconds to load.

What Slows You Down:

  • Huge, uncompressed images

  • Too many JavaScript plugins

  • Cheap or overloaded hosting

  • Lack of a global CDN

Note: Many times a developer will be needed for best results.

Speed Up Your Site:

  • Convert images to WebP and compress them.

  • Use a CDN like Cloudflare to serve global content faster.

  • Audit and remove unused scripts or plugins.

  • Invest in reliable, performance-optimized hosting.

đŸ§Ș Free Tools to Test Speed:

  • Google PageSpeed Insights

  • GTmetrix

  • Pingdom Tools


✅ Fix #7: No Urgency

Why It Matters:
Even if someone is interested, they might say “I’ll come back later” — and never do. Urgency gives them a reason to act now.

Tactics to Create Urgency:

  • Countdown timers show deadlines visually.

  • Stock counters indicate scarcity (e.g., “Only 3 seats left!”).

  • Time-limited discounts encourage immediate action.

  • Exclusive first-visitor offers reward quick decisions.

đŸ”„ Examples:

  • “Only available until midnight”

  • “Next slot opens in 2 weeks”

  • “Use code NEW10 before it expires”


đŸ› ïž Implementation Roadmap

Break improvements into weekly sprints for focus and momentum:

📅 Week 1 Priorities

  • Revise your homepage headline to clearly show value.

  • Improve or rewrite your primary CTA buttons.

  • Run a site speed audit and fix the top bottlenecks.

📅 Week 2 Focus

  • Shorten and simplify your lead forms.

  • Add or update customer testimonials and trust logos.

  • Test and fix your mobile layout and usability.

📅 Week 3 Actions

  • Introduce urgency-driven content (timers, stock notices).

  • Launch A/B tests on CTAs, forms, and hero sections.

  • Fine-tune the checkout process to reduce abandonment.


🎯 Measurement Strategy

Track improvements using real data — otherwise you’re guessing.

Key Metrics to Monitor:

  • Conversion rate by traffic source (e.g., paid vs organic)

  • Page-specific conversion rates to identify weak spots

  • Form completion rates to monitor friction

  • Mobile vs desktop performance to catch UX gaps

Recommended Tools:

  • Google Analytics 4 for detailed user behavior

  • Hotjar or Crazy Egg for heatmaps and user recordings

  • Optimizely, VWO, or Google Optimize for A/B testing


⚡ Quick Wins (Do These Today)

These high-impact tweaks can be done in a day — and often bring immediate results:

  1. Rewrite your main headline to speak directly to customer outcomes and pain points.

  2. Update CTA button text with specific, benefit-focused action language.

  3. Add a testimonial with a photo above the fold or near the CTA.

  4. Remove extra form fields — leave only what’s essential.

  5. Test your mobile site on several devices and fix anything awkward or broken.


đŸ§Ș A/B Testing Framework

Testing helps you learn what actually works instead of guessing.

What to Test:

  • Different headlines and subheadlines

  • Button colors, shapes, and text

  • Number of form fields or layout styles

  • Placement and type of social proof

Best Practices:

  • Test one element at a time to isolate the effect.

  • Run until you reach statistical significance (100+ conversions per variation).

  • Always document results — win or lose — for future reference.

  • Rotate tests regularly and set a hypothesis before starting.


🚀 Bottom Line

Fixing your conversion rate doesn’t always require a massive redesign. Often, it's a series of small, strategic changes that compound over time. Focus on clarity, trust, speed, and action — and watch your conversions climb.


Let me know if you'd like this turned into a PDF, HTML blog format, or if you want design suggestions for implementation!

Tell us about
your project.

Our offices

  • Florida
    610 E Zack St. Ste 110-2177
    Tampa, FL 33602